Cover of 'The Fall Of The House Of Usher' by E.A. Poe, featuring stylized graphic elements and a faded background.

Rating: 7 out of 10 stars

Rating: 7 out of 10.

Spoilers!

My first time reading this was in high school, and I remember thinking even then that it was a bit too melodramatic. Don’t get me wrong, it’s good. I think the end takes it a bit too far and requires far too much suspension of disbelief. I appreciate the creepy vibes Poe creates from description, however.

The story starts with a phrase in French: “Son coeur est un luth suspendu sitôt qu’on le touche il résonne,” which means “His heart is a suspended lute; as soon as it is touched, it resounds.”

After some thought, I believe this saying refers to the fact that Roderick Usher can only handle the music of some stringed instruments and has become super sensitive to various stimuli. That is the reason, after all, that the narrator has come to visit his dear friend. Roderick is suffering from a “mental disorder which oppressed him.” Roderick can only handle insipid food, garments of a certain texture, and all odors (including pleasant ones) he cannot stand.

Some of these sensitivities seem to suggest he may be autistic, but I’m no expert. All of my partners have been autistic though and some of their traits are similar, so it does seem possible. It is interesting to see how neurodivergence was regarded in the past, though often sad.

Not only is Roderick on the edge of a mental breakdown, his sister is also dying of a disease that has “long baffled the skill of physicians.” When she finally dies, she is put in a coffin in the family vault.

Except she’s not dead yet. So over a period of days she claws her way out and finds her way to her brother. When she finds him, she collapses on him and ultimately dies for real. The shock is too much for Roderick and he dies as well. Then as the narrator leaves, the entire House of Usher is swallowed up by the earth.

See what I mean? Melodrama at its finest. I think the story might have been better off even if the house just still stood, serving as the final tomb of Usher family.

What are your thoughts on this timeless classic? Were you also put off by the melodrama? Feel free to comment on your thoughts below!


Discover more from P. A. Wilson,

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Trending